Silver City Church
Sermon Study Guide

Blessed Are the Peacemakers

Matthew 5:9 | The Beatitudes, Part 7
Sermon Overview tap to collapse

In 1964, students at UC Berkeley cracked under the weight of a world telling them they meant nothing. A war they didn't believe in, a Cold War that could end everything overnight, and classrooms informing them they were just carbon drifting through space. Within a few years, the hippie movement was born: two fingers held up in a V, a hand sign for peace with nothing behind it. An anesthetic, not a cure.

That's the pit we fall into with this beatitude. When we hear "peacemakers" we picture communes and tie-dye and everyone loving everyone with no particular reason to. But that was never peace. That was numbness.

Jesus gives us something entirely different: a kingdom ethic of true peace that makes those who have it and make it into something worth more than anything they could dream of being -- sons of God.

The word "peacemaker" appears only once in the entire Bible, right here. But it's a compound word, peace plus maker, and both halves run all through scripture. Paul uses the verb form of this same word to describe what Jesus did on the cross: "making peace by the blood of his cross" (Colossians 1:20). That's where this beatitude lives.

Biblical peace is not a mood. It's a relationship. The Old Testament word is shalom: wholeness, well-being in every direction, with your neighbor and above all with God. The New Testament word, eirene, carries the same weight. Peace is not merely the absence of conflict. It is right relationship, with God and with others, that shows itself in a settled, holy, trustworthy life. Twenty-six of the twenty-seven books of the New Testament use the word peace, and most often it describes who God is ("the God of peace") and what He has done in giving us salvation.

The peace offering is one of the clearest Old Testament pictures. Unlike most sacrifices, it was voluntary -- brought not because you had to, but because your heart overflowed with thanks. The animal had to be without blemish. The fat was the Lord's. And then came what made it unlike every other sacrifice: you got to eat it. The worshiper, with his family, sat down and ate the meat in the presence of God. A family dinner, with the Lord at the table. The very animal that died in his place became the food that fed him. That is how God makes peace: not hippie vibes, not just ending the fighting, but going straight through the conflict at His own cost to reconcile the estranged party, and then setting a table for him.

The Prince of Peace is the fulfillment of everything the peace offering pointed to. He would be called the Prince of Peace (Isaiah 9:6). At His birth, angels sang "on earth peace" (Luke 2:14). On the cross, God was in Christ reconciling the world to Himself (2 Corinthians 5:19). In His own body He made one new man out of Jew and Gentile, tearing down the dividing wall (Ephesians 2:14-16). And when He rose and walked into that locked room where His frightened disciples were hiding, His first words were, "Peace be with you" (John 20:19). He doesn't just give peace. "He himself is our peace" (Ephesians 2:14).

And those who have received this radical, costly peace go out and make that same kind of costly peace in the power of the Spirit. What will they be called? Sons of God. In the ancient world, sons were the heirs. Sons got the name and the inheritance. And Paul says, "in Christ Jesus you are all sons of God, through faith" (Galatians 3:26). Every man, woman, and child in Christ gets the full inheritance rights of the firstborn Son.

The application presses this into four concrete directions. First: you cannot give away a peace you have never received. Have the war between you and God ended? "Since we have been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ" (Romans 5:1). Come to the table first. Second: peacemakers go first. God didn't wait for us to come crawling back. While we were still enemies, He came to us. His sons look like their Father. They make the call, knock on the door, write the letter. Third: a peacemaker is not a peace monger. Peace without truth is a truce, an anesthetic. Sometimes peacemaking looks like a sword cutting through a false peace. Truth that isn't loving is a club; love that won't tell the truth is cowardice. Fourth: when peace isn't possible yet, keep the door open. Some people will refuse your peace no matter how many times you offer it. That's not failure. That's the cross.

Remember those two fingers in 1967? Our King didn't hold up two fingers. He stretched out two hands and let them be nailed to a cross. Three days later He walked into a room full of frightened, guilty men, held up those same scarred hands, and said, "Peace be with you." And then, just like the peace offering, He set a table. Come and sit at your Father's table, sons of God. Then get up and go make peace, because you look like Him now.

Key Takeaways tap to expand
1. Biblical peace is a relationship, not a mood.
Shalom and eirene both mean wholeness and right relationship, not the absence of noise or the feeling of calm. Peace begins upstream, with God bridging the gap our sin created by sending His Son to live, die, and rise in our place. Twenty-six of the twenty-seven books of the New Testament use this word, almost always in terms of who God is and what He has done. Peace is not something you work yourself into. It is something you receive from outside yourself.
2. The peace offering shows what God's peace actually looks like.
It was voluntary, brought from overflow, not obligation. The animal had to be without blemish. And after the sacrifice, the worshiper sat down and ate in the presence of God, a family dinner with the Lord at the head. The animal that died in his place became the meal that fed him. That is the shape of reconciliation: God goes through the conflict at His own cost and then sets a table. Nothing like hippie peace. Everything like the cross.
3. Jesus is not merely the giver of peace. He is our peace.
Paul doesn't say Jesus gives us peace the way a store clerk hands you a receipt. He says "he himself is our peace" (Ephesians 2:14). He is the fulfillment of every peace offering, the Prince of Peace Isaiah promised, the one who made one new man out of Jew and Gentile in His own body, whose first words to His frightened disciples after the resurrection were "Peace be with you." The peace we make flows out of a peace we have been given, in Him.
4. Sons of God is not a gender statement. It is an inheritance statement.
In the ancient world, sons were the heirs. The language is not exclusive; it is extravagant. Paul makes this explicit: "in Christ Jesus you are all sons of God, through faith" (Galatians 3:26). Every person in Christ -- man, woman, child -- receives the full inheritance rights of the firstborn Son. Ladies in the church are sons. Men in the church are the bride of Christ. The gospel keeps handing us titles that shouldn't fit, because the inheritance is bigger than any category we bring to it.
5. A peacemaker is not a peace monger.
God condemned the false prophets of Jeremiah's day for saying "Peace, peace" when there was no peace (Jeremiah 6:14). A peace monger smooths things over so nobody has to be uncomfortable. A peacemaker is willing to be uncomfortable, even willing to be hated for a while, because he wants the real thing. Jesus said He came not to bring peace but a sword (Matthew 10:34). He wasn't contradicting this beatitude. He was saying real peace sometimes has to cut through a false one. Truth that isn't loving is just a club; love that won't tell the truth is just cowardice.
Weekly Devotional tap to expand

Five days of reflection rooted in Sunday's sermon. Each day opens its own reading and prayer.

Day 1 -- Shalom: What Peace Actually Means
Scripture: Romans 5:1-11; Ephesians 2:13-18
Theme: Peace as right relationship, not right feeling

We inherit a thin version of peace from the culture around us: no loud arguments, a calm week, no major disasters. But the biblical word is richer and more demanding. Shalom means wholeness in every direction, with God and with neighbor, mind and body, inside and out. And eirene in the New Testament carries the same weight. It is not a mood you can maintain by managing your circumstances carefully enough.

Paul makes the source explicit: "Since we have been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ" (Romans 5:1). The peace isn't the downstream feeling of a good week. It is the upstream fact of a war ended. God and man were enemies. Christ's work ended that war. Everything that follows, including the calm in your soul on a hard Tuesday, is the downstream effect of that settled reality.

Reflect: When you think about peace, what comes to mind first -- a feeling or a fact? How does it change your daily life to think of peace as something already given rather than something you have to maintain?

Pray: Lord, help me to stand on the peace I have already been given rather than scrambling to manufacture a feeling. You ended the war. Let me live like it.

Day 2 -- The Peace Offering: A Meal, Not Just a Sacrifice
Scripture: Leviticus 7:11-21; Colossians 1:19-22
Theme: Reconciliation ends at the table, not the altar

Most of us think of Old Testament sacrifice as grim and mechanical: you bring an animal, the priest kills it, you go home. But the peace offering was different. After the blood was shed and the fat burned as the Lord's portion, the worshiper got to eat. He sat down with his family in the presence of God and had a meal. A family dinner with the Lord at the table. The animal that died in his place became the food that sustained him.

That is not grim. That is the most intimate picture of reconciliation in the Old Testament. God doesn't just wipe your record clean and send you home. He pulls up a chair. He sets a table. He welcomes you into fellowship. The peace offering was not the end of worship; it was the shape of it: gratitude, nearness, shared bread, the Lord at the head of the table.

Paul picks this up in Colossians 1: God reconciled us "in his body of flesh by his death," and the aim was not merely legal -- it was relational: to present us "holy and blameless and above reproach before him." Not just pardoned. Present.

Reflect: Do you think of your relationship with God as primarily legal (pardoned/not pardoned) or relational (welcomed, present, seated at His table)? What would it look like to lean more into the relational side this week?

Pray: Father, You didn't just pardon me and send me away. You set a table. Help me to actually sit at it today, not anxiously, but with the ease of a child who knows they are welcome.

Day 3 -- He Himself Is Our Peace
Scripture: Ephesians 2:14-18; John 20:19-23
Theme: Jesus is not the giver of peace. He is peace.

There is a significant difference between someone who gives you a gift and someone who is the gift. Paul is startlingly direct: "he himself is our peace" (Ephesians 2:14). Jesus did not simply broker a deal between God and man. He became the meeting point, the mediator in His own person, reconciling both parties in one body by the cross.

That means your peace is not a commodity that could be lost if Jesus went away, or a contract that could expire. It is a person. The Prince of Peace, who came singing shalom through the locked door into a room full of frightened, guilty men and said simply, "Peace be with you." And then He showed them His hands. The peace He spoke over them had been purchased in those hands. It was not abstract. It was scarred.

When anxiety rises and peace feels far away, the answer is not to try harder to feel calm. It is to look again at the person who is your peace, the risen Jesus with scarred hands, standing in your room, speaking the same word to you.

Reflect: What is the difference in practice between seeking peace as a feeling to be achieved and seeking Jesus as the person who is your peace? Where do you most need to make that shift right now?

Pray: Lord Jesus, You are my peace. Not what You give me when things go well, but You yourself. Help me today to look at You rather than at my circumstances, and to receive what You have already spoken: peace.

Day 4 -- Peacemakers Go First
Scripture: Matthew 5:23-24; Romans 5:10; 2 Corinthians 5:18-20
Theme: Children of God look like their Father -- they initiate

Thomas Watson observed something painfully true about human nature: we are like people watching an eclipse. The sun shines on us every day and we barely glance at it, but let there be one eclipse and the whole country drives three hours and stares at the sky. We do the same thing with the people around us. Someone can walk in faithfulness for twenty years, and we barely notice. Let them have one sharp word, one failure, one dark afternoon, and we pull up a lawn chair and stare at it for the rest of our lives.

The peacemaker learns to look at the sun when it's shining. He notices the grace of God in his brother before he catalogs his faults. And when there is a rupture, he goes first. Jesus is not subtle about this: leave your gift at the altar, go, be reconciled, then come back (Matthew 5:23-24). Don't finish the offering. The relationship is more urgent than the religious act.

God modeled this. While we were still enemies, He came to us (Romans 5:10). He didn't wait for us to clean up and come crawling back. His sons and daughters look like Him. They make the call. They knock on the door. They write the letter.

Reflect: Who are you waiting for to come to you first? What would it look like to go first this week, not because you are in the wrong, but because you look like your Father?

Pray: Father, You went first at infinite cost. Give me the grace and the courage to go first at the small cost You are asking of me right now. Make me look like You.

Day 5 -- When Peace Isn't Possible Yet
Scripture: Romans 12:17-21; Proverbs 19:11; Matthew 10:34-36
Theme: Faithfulness when reconciliation is refused

Paul is honest about the limits: "If possible, so far as it depends on you, live peaceably with all" (Romans 12:18). Two significant qualifiers: "if possible" and "so far as it depends on you." He knew, and we need to hear, that some people will refuse your peace no matter how many times you offer it. You cannot force reconciliation. You can only offer it, repeatedly, at cost, without bitterness.

Jesus offered peace to people who spat in His face. That is not a failure of peacemaking; that is the cross. The offering of peace is not conditional on its reception. You do what depends on you: overlook what you can (Proverbs 19:11), speak truth where you must, refuse bitterness, pray for them, and keep the door open. The goal is not to win. The goal is to leave nothing on your side that would prevent reconciliation if the day ever comes when the other person is ready.

That may be a long obedience. It may feel like carrying something heavy for a long time. But it is the shape of the cross, and it is the shape of sonship. Sons of God look like the Son of God, even when it costs them.

Reflect: Is there a relationship in your life where you've tried to make peace and been refused? What does "so far as it depends on you" look like practically in that situation, and what does keeping the door open require of you right now?

Pray: Lord, give me the grace to hold the door open without bitterness. Where I have no power to reconcile, give me the peace that surpasses understanding, and do what only You can do in that other person's heart.

Reflection & Application Questions tap to expand

For personal study or group discussion.

1. The sermon opened with the hippie movement as a picture of counterfeit peace -- an anesthetic with nothing behind it. Where in your own life are you tempted to settle for numbness or surface calm rather than the real peace that comes from right relationship with God and others?

2. The peace offering ended with a meal -- the worshiper eating in the presence of God. How does that image of fellowship, not just pardon, shape the way you think about what God has given you in Christ? Do you live more like someone who has been pardoned and sent home, or like someone who has been welcomed to the table?

3. Paul says Jesus "himself is our peace" (Ephesians 2:14) -- not merely the giver of it. What is the practical difference between seeking peace as a feeling to maintain and looking to Jesus as the person who is your peace?

4. The sermon used Thomas Watson's eclipse illustration: we stare at the one dark moment and barely notice twenty years of faithfulness. Who in your life have you done this to? What would it look like to notice the light rather than cataloging the shadow?

5. Jesus says in Matthew 5:23-24 to leave your offering at the altar and go be reconciled first. Is there a relationship where you are waiting for someone else to come to you first? What would it mean for you to go first this week, regardless of who is in the wrong?

6. The sermon drew a sharp line between a peacemaker and a peace monger -- someone who avoids the conflict that real peace requires. Are you avoiding a hard conversation or a necessary confrontation and calling it keeping the peace? What does "truth in love" (Ephesians 4:15) require of you in that situation?

7. Paul says "if possible, so far as it depends on you, live peaceably with all" (Romans 12:18). Some people will refuse your peace. Is there a situation in your life right now where you have done what depends on you and the door is still closed? What does faithfulness look like in that season, and what does keeping bitterness out look like practically?

Scripture References tap to expand
Matthew 5:9
"Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God." -- The beatitude anchoring the sermon.
Isaiah 9:6
"Prince of Peace" -- Jesus' title foretold, the one this beatitude ultimately points to.
Colossians 1:20
"Making peace by the blood of his cross" -- Paul uses the verb form of "peacemaker" to describe what Christ did.
Ephesians 2:14-16
"He himself is our peace" -- not merely its giver; He made one new man out of Jew and Gentile in His own body.
Romans 5:1
"Since we have been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ." -- The upstream source of all peacemaking.
John 20:19-20
The risen Christ walks into the locked room, shows His scarred hands, and speaks: "Peace be with you." Peace purchased, then proclaimed.
Matthew 5:23-24
Leave your offering at the altar, go be reconciled to your brother first. Relationship is more urgent than religious act.
Galatians 3:26; 4:7
"In Christ Jesus you are all sons of God, through faith... if a son, then an heir through God." -- Every believer receives the full inheritance of the firstborn Son.
Jeremiah 6:14
"Peace, peace, when there is no peace." -- God's condemnation of false peacemaking that heals wounds lightly.
Romans 12:18
"If possible, so far as it depends on you, live peaceably with all." -- The honest qualifier: you can only do your part.
James 3:17-18
"The wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable" and "a harvest of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace." -- The closing word of the sermon.
Westminster Confession Connection tap to expand

How the Reformed confessions speak to what we heard Sunday.

WSC Q.33 -- Justification
"Justification is an act of God's free grace, wherein he pardoneth all our sins, and accepteth us as righteous in his sight, only for the righteousness of Christ imputed to us, and received by faith alone."
This is the foundation of all peacemaking. The sermon pressed the question plainly: has the war between you and God ended? Justification is the answer. God pardon's every sin and counts the sinner righteous, not for anything in the sinner, but for the righteousness of Christ alone received by faith. That is the peace at the upstream. Every act of peacemaking flows from that declared peace. You cannot give away what you have not received.
WLC Q.135 -- The Sixth Commandment
"The duties required in the sixth commandment are, all careful studies, and lawful endeavors, to preserve the life of ourselves and others... a readiness to be reconciled, patient bearing and forgiving of injuries, and requiting good for evil..."
The catechism ties peacemaking directly to the sixth commandment -- you shall not murder. The positive side of that command is not merely not killing people. It includes a readiness to be reconciled, patience that bears and forgives injury, and a determination to repay evil with good. Refusing to make peace is not a neutral failure to be nice. It is the quiet cousin of the very sin that commandment forbids. The peacemaker's posture is built in here: go first, bear the injury, return good for evil.
WCF 12 -- Adoption
"All those that are justified, God vouchsafeth, in and for His only Son Jesus Christ, to make partakers of the grace of adoption, by which they are taken into the number, and enjoy the liberties and privileges of the children of God, have His name put upon them..."
"Sons of God" is not an aspirational title for the especially holy. It is the declared status of everyone who is in Christ, given by adoption. The confession says God's name is put upon them. Children bear their Father's name, and they bear His family likeness. That is the theological engine beneath the application: peacemakers look like their Father because they are His children, adopted into the same Son whose very title is Prince of Peace. We make peace because we have been made sons.
Silver City Church | The Beatitudes | Matthew 5:9